Skip to content

What can we expect from COP 27? A personal view

The 27th Conference of Parties (COP) meeting on climate change organised by the United Nations is being held on 6-18 November 2022, at Sharm El-Sheikh, an Egyptian holiday resort on the Red Sea coast of the Sinai Peninsula. As many as 35,000 delegates, including politicians (with up to 100 heads of state), scientists and representatives of business, academic organisations and civil society, will assess the targets and progress for limiting global warming that were set at COP 26 held in Glasgow in 2021.

Sharm El-Sheikh is a city of about 75,000 people and was last headline news in 2015 when a terrorist bomb caused the crash of a Russian chartered flight, killing 224 people. A week later Russian and UK nationals had to be repatriated from the resort.

Egypt, only the fourth African country since 1995 to host a COP meeting after South Africa, Kenya and Morocco, faces significant challenges from climate change; by the end of this century it is estimated that the effects on the Nile Delta of rising sea level, subsidence and salt penetration will lead to the displacement of up to 1 million people and the loss of a significant proportion of the country’s agricultural land.

COP 26 in Glasgow upheld the aim of limiting global warming to well below 2oC, with a rise of 1.5oC regarded as the ‘safe’ upper limit, which was set at COP 21 (Paris) in 2015. For the first time it was also agreed to ‘phase down’ the burning of coal and to ‘phase out’ fossil fuel subsidies. Financial pledges to help poorer countries adapt to climate change and to switch to clean energy sources were reinforced. However, a review of Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) to reductions in greenhouse gas emissions indicated that, even after taking account of commitments by several major countries (including the UK) to reach net zero by 2050, the world was on course to warm by about 2.5oC.

Little has been achieved on climate change over the last year mainly because of the war in Europe with its consequent effects on global fuel and food prices and on policy differences between EU countries over energy subsidies, and because of the worsening relations between the US and China. Slowdowns in emissions of CO2 and in the rise atmospheric CO2 during the covid pandemic are now reversed. Global warming already stands at about 1.1oC. The frequency and cost of extreme climate events continue to increase around the world, examples being storm Eunice in February and a heatwave/drought in June-August which affected W Europe in 2022. Within the last year only 24 countries out of a total of nearly 200 have submitted improved NDCs.

The COP process for tackling climate change is cumbersome and slow but it is the only one we have. COP 27 will need to examine once again the work programmes dealing with mitigation and adaptation and must focus on how industrialised nations should compensate developing countries for environmental losses and damage attributable to the burning of fossil fuels. The target of $100 billion a year for climate finance, set in 2009 to be reached in 2020, is now unlikely to be attained before 2025. Furthermore, loans to poor countries for adaptation to climate change are still subject to interest payments that will never be paid. We must hope that compromises can be made but it is difficult to be optimistic about the outcome of COP 27 in the absence of greater trust and understanding between countries.

Perhaps the most difficult issue is inequity between rich and poor. Across the globe the richest 1% of people through their consumption and investment practices produce about 15% of total greenhouse gases (equivalent to 48 tonnes of CO2 per person) whereas the poorest 50% produce just 10% (1 tonne CO2 p.p.) and often lack the means to protect themselves against the wider impacts of climate change and to benefit fully from renewable energy. We must hope that COP 27 can find better pathways to the equitable sharing of resources, both within and between countries, and to changing human behaviour in ways that protect the natural world and respect the needs of future generations. We have the technological means and knowledge to do both, but the capitalist system often stands in the way. It is disturbing that public relations for COP 27 are being handled by a company with strong links to the tobacco and fossil fuel industries and that COP 28 is to be hosted by an oil-rich country.

Recent progress by the UK towards tackling the challenges of climate change has been slow. The Net Zero Strategy published in 2021 has resulted in relatively little action. New licenses are about to be granted for oil and gas drilling in the North Sea, and subsidies continue to be given to fossil fuel companies as tax offsets. We continue to lack honesty about our greenhouse gas emissions by failing to include those associated with imported goods and with international travel. New houses are still being completed with gas boilers and substandard insulation but no solar panels or EV charging points. Programmes to improve the insulation of older houses have been all but halted. Public transport does not meet the needs of the public. Although offshore wind turbines have been one success, the building of cheaper onshore turbines has been curtailed and funding for tidal turbines, the one source of renewable energy unaffected by fluctuations in weather conditions, has been withdrawn. Protections for natural capital remain weak especially with respect to soils, peatlands, woodlands and aquatic environments. Finally, the UK, a microcosm of the wider world, has recently made cuts in overseas aid to poorer countries.

Patrick Holligan.    6 November, 2022.