As part of the ‘Impacts of New Housebuilding’ Focus, Abingdon Carbon Cutters hosted Dr Sue Roberts on 16 October 2024 to talk about biodiversity loss and carbon emissions from housebuilding. Dr Roberts is a former South Oxfordshire District Councillor, who is part of The Bioabundance Community Interest Company, which campaigns to secure a safe future where we can thrive within the natural world.
The audience of 20 were deeply engaged in how better use could be made of the existing inefficient and largely under-occupied housing stock and how this could be improved. As a zoologist by training Sue started with comments on the extent of biodiversity loss attributable to urban development and moved on to the significance of carbon emitted in building houses and associated infrastructure and services.
The talk happened to coincide with the consultation on the deposit draft joint local plan for South Oxfordshire and the Vale of White Horse and included a number of points that could be made before it closed. The position has been confused by changes in the Government expectations in terms of housing numbers, that have gone down but are now expected to rise. There are a number of tests of ‘soundness’ that the plan will have to meet in its examination which include compliance with both the relevant law (which includes the Climate Change Act and requires climate change mitigation) and the National Planning Policy Framework (which has previously been found to be legally flawed in respect of carbon budgets and will be tested again in May 2025) and which the Government is currently revising to encourage even more development as an engine for growth of GDP. Sue had been a Green Deal assessor and described the failure for this and other schemes to upgrade the stock of about 29m houses and explained how new housebuilding will drain resources from the necessary retrofitting. Finally, we were encouraged to complete the survey on the One Planet Abingdon web site, that Sue had helped to draft, and to spread the word to increase the number of responses and usefulness of the results.

Here are the full notes from the talk:
Smoke Perhaps it was 150 years ago, perhaps longer. The bats were a nuisance, hanging from the vaulted church ceiling, and of course performing their natural functions. The solution was the usual one. Burners filled the church with suffocating smoke. The bats dropped. A relay of church-goers shovelled the tiny corpses into wheelbarrows; removing barrow-load after barrow-load. Such was the bioabundance that we once knew.
Baseline We talk with dismay of the diminishment of animal and plant numbers since 2000. In 2000 we compared with 1970. Prior to that records were less good; but we have anecdotes of extraordinary abundance. This is the effect of shifting baselines. This is exemplified in the WWF-ZSL Living Planet Report that came out on Thursday showing since 1970 a 73% reduction in global vertebrates (so not including insects and worms). Europe was 35% and Latin America 95%. The lower losses in Europe are because of the lower baseline we had already reached, by degrading our nature prior to 1970. Our nature-depleted country, ranks in the 10% worst in the world.
Our losses Marley was just 3 in February, when I took him, as I have done with children for the past 34 years, to the duck-feeding station in Wallingford. The coots and grebes vanished years ago, and lately, seagulls have started to appear. But we could always, always see ducks. Not this time. Not this year at all. No ducks, no swans, no moorhens, not even the surprise seagulls. The river is completely empty. Nature is slipping quietly away. 14y ago our Wallingford home was visited by not only grey but also red-legged partridges. They quickly vanished; followed by the starlings 7y ago; the jackdaws 4y ago; goldfinches 2y ago; town pigeons (cleansed by pigeon spikes) a year ago. Now we have only the occasional wood pigeon.
Tangled web Does this matter? As they vanish, people ask, ‘but what is the point of bats’, or of wasps? or of stag beetles? Take away wasps and waste matter is not broken down; rabbits keep grass short for wild flowers; ash trees provide shade, beauty, and timber. But it goes deeper than single effects of individual species. We are part of the deep interconnectedness of plants and animals that has evolved into a complex tangled web of dependencies. Take one brick out of the Jenga block of an ecosystem and the whole lot may twist and change or come tumbling down. RPSB’s January report was titled “Without nature, there is no food”. Nature brings us clean water, clean air, pollination, flood control, carbon storage, breakdown of waste, wellbeing. Our insects have almost gone. Urgent action is needed.
America In July, we learnt of the vital role bats play in America. Bats eat 40% of their own weight each day, and control insect crop-pests, but in some states they have been wiped out by a new fungus from Europe which arrived in 2006. In response, farmers upped their insecticide use by a third. In these states, compared to others the bat fungus had not reached, increased toxicity from pesticides was measurable as an 8% increase in human infant mortality: 1334 baby-deaths over 11 years could be attributed to the loss of bats.
Environment Act of 2021 legally binds us to reversing the decline in nature by 2030. We are not on-track to do this.
Fragmentation Land-use-change is the major driver of nature loss: particularly farming and development. Every square metre of concrete laid, destroys the subtle and complex living structure of the soil beneath, and reduces land available for nature. Fragmentation of land however, is what worries me most. A new estate is one thing blocking nature, but the roads to it immediately bisect and enclose land. Slow-moving hedgehogs and stag beetles cannot cross. Plants cannot cross. A continent is reduced to small islands, where once-vibrant populations wither and die. Bright lights from homes attract and kill insects, and throw the natural light-dark cycles of all of nature into disarray. Traffic noise disorients and disturbs nature.
Carbon The natural world is also vital for carbon sequestration. On Monday we learned that in 2023, for the first time, the land: that is forests, plants and soil, absorbed almost no carbon*. Normally they would take up a quarter of our emissions. Heat, fire and land-clearance has reduced carbon uptake.
Current impacts Look at what has already happened to us at only 1.2deg warming. Shocking floods this year throughout the County: in Wheatley, Abingdon, Oxford. This gets worse as heating intensifies: warm air has more energy in it for furious storms; it holds more water; and the jet stream is disrupted, dumping water on us. This year’s floods have decreased our agricultural yield by 30%.
Parts of the world are becoming uninhabitable with temperature highs of 55deg, driving ever-increasing migration. The two biggest hurricanes ever-recorded have hit the US. As mediterranean countries desertify we lose our sources of imported vegetables and fruit. Across the world bread basket failures are occurring. We face flood, drought, overheating, unseasonable cold snaps, and huge food price inflation.
How much to emit The Tyndall Centre, a UK (and Shanghai) collaboration of scientists has calculated carbon budgets by district to keep us close to 1.5deg warming. South Oxfordshire may emit 5.6m T of CO2.
Development Hold that figure in your head. 5.6mT. As we build the 23,500 homes that the last government forced us to plan for; just in the building of those homes, we shall emit 5.9mT of CO2. Development then, more than uses up our carbon budget. And we have all our usual emissions to take care of as well.
Carbon and Trees I base the 5.9mT on data from Taylor Wimpey showing an average releases of 250T of CO2 per housebuild. How could we offset that with carbon capture? With trees? We’d need 15m mature trees to work for the whole year as we build out 1200 homes a year in South Oxfordshire’s. There are 280m trees in the whole of England and Wales. As for 370,000 housebuilds per year as the Government desires (creating 93mT of emissions); we’d need 4.6 billion mature trees, for housing in England alone, working all year to suck up the emissions. In the whole UK there are 3bn; 2/3 of what is required.
South and Vale Local Plan currently in consultation sets embodied carbon at 30T for a 100m2 house floor-plan (larger developments only). 23,500 homes would then emit a total of 700,000T, using up 12% of our budget. But this (I believe) is just for the house itself, not for the associated infrastructure (roads, community buildings etc) which would likely take us back up to 80T.
Need for homes The housing affordability crisis is critical, unfair and cruel. Under the Government’s revised National Planning Policy Framework, more expensive areas would have to build a huge number of extra homes against their formula, without limit. That applies to us, here, and doubles the number of houses to be built in South Oxfordshire. It is totally illogical. This is not a normal demand-supply market. Increasing the supply of homes does not bring down their price. We have the bitter experience of that in Oxfordshire where house prices inflation has increased since we increased housebuilding. In an almost infinite market, more housing draws the eye of the international investor. Look up Ian Mulheirn https://medium.com/@ian.mulheirn, economist at the Resolution Foundation to learn how decent housing is out-of-reach because of low incomes and benefits and not because of housing supply.
Where to find more units? How to bring down house prices? House prices would settle if the market were restricted. Homes should be for residential purposes only and should be sold only to those living or intending to live within an area; with any holiday provision being limited and licensed by the local council. If you did need more housing units, we could fill the 1.5m homes that are not occupied**. Build out the 1m permissions that are being land-banked. And Dan’s idea of cusping: 3/4 of Oxfordshire homes are underoccupied with one, or more usually two or more, empty rooms.
Retrofit We have limited resources. We have two few tradespeople and builders, and supplies of building materials are costly. These resources should go into retrofitting our 29 million homes. Retrofitting could reduce our carbon emissions by a quarter, would eliminate fuel poverty, reduce winter and summer deaths – insulating us against cold and heat, and provide fuel security. We need not build as much electrical infrastructure if we need less energy and can manage demand better. Currently our homes produce 1/5 of our emissions. It would take a moonshot to do this. It needs all our trades to be focussed on this complex tasks. It would provide more habitable units. Resources cannot be shared with unnecessary and damaging house-building.
Economic growth This Government has been unequivocal in stating that the point of housebuilding is for economic growth – they scarcely mention housing people any more. Certainly our Local Plan was for that purpose. We set up Bioabundance Community Interest Company in 2020 to challenge the South Oxfordshire Local Plan. There, our growing population could fill only a quarter of the homes set to be built: three empty homes would be created for every four new homes. Alternatlvely, London could empty out leaving vacant investment houses, as people move to where new housing is appearing.
BNG Bizarrely, Govt claim that development will improve nature. Biodiversity net gain (BNG) requires development to make good nature losses – a Polluter Pays principle. But BNG is only 10% net gain – which is effectively a buffer to stand still. It needs to be much higher so that nature could be genuinely improved with one hand as we destroy it with another.
Yesterday, the Local Nature Recovery Strategy for Oxfordshire was supposed to be published. It shows where swathes of nature should be restored. These maps need to make there way into Local Plans which should delimit, protect and plan for nature recovery, instead of planning strategic sites for development.
How to do development:
1) Zero carbon construction – build in wood Ian Pritchett Greencore – Springfield Meadows Southmoor,
2) Zero carbon operation – solar panels, heat pumps, airtightness, ventilation systems and insulation: Passivhaus level
3) Within nature-rich areas and restoration all around – Ian worked with BBOWT to protect nature on his development.
4) Housing should be for social rent which should once again become aspirational.
5) Development should be car-free with excellent public transport like the BEDZED homes by Brighton Station or the whole town of Pontevedra in Spain.
6) Homes should be focussed on good living – facing towards one another with spaces for children and socialisation such as the award-winning Goldsmith estate of 93 Passivhaus social housing homes in Norwich.
Marmalade Lane 2ml from central Cambridge is an example of privately owned homes in an ‘intentional community’ where all have their own complete homes but have a communal house with a large kitchen and dining room; laundry; and spare rooms for visitors; and communal grounds. Forty one homes share 3 or 4 cars.
But all development is problematic. I would say “Absolutely fine in an unconstrained world, concrete over our land – create money from it – but not when we are in a climate and nature catastrophe”.
*https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/oct/14/nature-carbon-sink-collapse-global-heating-models-emissions-targets-evidence-aoe
** https://ww3.rics.org/uk/en/modus/built-environment/homes-and-communities/britains-empty-homes.html
